For three glorious winters a decade ago, a cheerful bearded fat man delivered a trio of specatular and gorgeous Christmas treats to cinemas around the world. Rich in detail, monumental in scope and universally acclaimed, Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings is a supreme achievement in modern cinema. It would take a brave man to even attempt to repeat the feat.
And yet, after years of fannying about in development hell, last year came An Unexpected Journey. The first of a whole new trilogy of Tolkeiny goodness, a chance to revisit Middle Earth and relive some of those precious memories.
Or that was the idea, anyway. Unfortunately for many, An Unexpected Journey never quite managed to take flight in the way that it's esteemed predecessors did. Dogged by pacing problems and sometimes lacking a certain magic that made the earlier trilogy so wonderful, it wasn't quite the immediate classic we'd hoped for. Of course, The Phantom Menace, this was not. Sure, it took a while to get going, but once it did it still had plenty going for it. Gollum, those wonderful middle earth vistas, hair raising action... Sir Ian in that big hat. It was all quite lovely, but it wasn't perfect.
So, one year on, where are we? What of Smaug?
Opening with a neat flashback in a familiar pub, Desolation breezes out of the gates and takes flight through a seeming infinity of action and plot towards a roaring climax with onehelluva dragon.
As with every Jackson film, we're clocking in here at close to three hours, but it's three very fast hours. Indeed, as strange as it sounds, I find myself wanting more time with these characters once the film closes out. After years of watching extended editions on DVD, the original trilogy became more like a mini series that I'd watch in dribs and drabs. Voluminous as this film is, it's clear to see some of the cuts he made that will surely be slotted back in come the inevitable extended DVD.
That being said, we're not missing any great detail here, and of course, many purists will gripe about the inflation of a slender tome into a 9 hour uber-trilogy, but to be honest anyone who does is missing the point. As an adaptation of a book, a few liberties are taken and Jackson crams in extra details from Tolkeins own writings, but... as a film, a slice of cinematic entertainment, it works very well indeed.
In fact, one can't quite shake the feeling that the film is trying to shake off the sins of its forebear: it's notably short on the plot-lite standing around on the first film, and heavy on the zippy action and story development of the earlier trilogy.
In trimming out much of the expositional mud that tainted the first film, here we have a pace and lightness that characterises Jacksons best work. A multitude of action sequences, each as dazzling and entertaining as the last clatter along while a plethora of characters and beasties zip across the screen in breathless fashion.
Of course the film isn't short of flaws. While all are fun, some of the action seems a tad unnecessary, particularly elements of the final Smaug showdown which runs a tad long. But it's a small gripe when other elements are so rousing. The much touted barrel set piece in particular is, excuse me, barrels of fun (sorry). A particular moment involving rotund dwarf Bombur had me grinning very widely indeed.
Meanwhile, Gandalfs adventures into the appendices continue to engage, although never quite take full flight despite the delightfully trippy introduction of big-bad Sauron.
The sprawling cast all seem to be having fun, and sink their teeth into the little screen time they're given. Of course, some of the dwarves inevitably become background fluff, but kudos must go to Lee Pace as nasty bastard Elf king Thranduil, who is a nice counterpoint to Elrond and Galadriel. Big up also to arian uber-hunk Orlando Bloom who almost steals the film as Legolas. His succession of ridiculously over the top but fun action beats is an obvious but pleasing nod to his famed over the top scenes in the original trilogy.
She-elf Tauriel is also decent addition, adding much needed femininity to an otherwise entirely blokey affair, although the hokey subplot about her and fit dwarf Kili is a bit lame, but it doesn't detract greatly from the rest of the film.
Stephen Fry is pleasingly unctuous as the self serving Master of Laketown, although a tad underused. It would be no surprise if many of his excised scenes end up in next years extended edition.
Elsewhere, we find Weta digital delivering awesome spectacle in the effects department, particularly with that titular dragon, who really is a sight to behold. Benedict Cumberbatch delivers a characteristically wicked performance, his voice echoing through the Dwarvish halls like a supersized Darth Vader. Much like the Gollum scene in the first film, his scenes with Bilbo are one of the highlights of the film.
Come the final cliffhanger ending (which may wind a few people up), it's hard to fault Jacksons effort. While still falling slightly short of his own very high bench mark, it's a definite improvement on part one. A succession of glorious New Zealand postcard views, wonderfully esoteric characters and spectacular action, Desolation of Smaug is tantalisingly close to being that new Middle Earth film we wanted. Good work, Sir.
Bring on part 3!
4/5
Thomas Shutt
**This review was originally written for York Vision
**This review was originally written for York Vision